Traditional vs Automated Payroll Software, which makes your work better? As you are in the boardroom, discuss your organisation’s future growth and financial stability with your leadership team. The most recurring issue that heats up in your mind is payroll inefficiencies. Every employee considered your organisation’s backbone expects timely and accurate pay, but errors in the payroll persist.
You are confused: Should you use traditional manual payroll methods or switch to automated payroll software for efficiency? On the one hand, traditional payroll software gives you a familiar and personal touch, whereas automated payroll software promises efficiency and precision, but at what cost? This debate concerns numbers and software, the evolution and future of work, and businesses with the ever-changing financial landscape.
Dive into the comparison of advantages and disadvantages between traditional payroll vs automated payroll software.
What is Manual Payroll?
Manual payroll is a traditional approach performed using spreadsheets and calculators. This type of calculation typically delivers a lot of time and effort, which makes an individual work harder rather than smarter. If and only in an organisation, there will be 10-50 employees or more since every company is progressive. Managing each employee’s pay scale with deductions and other criteria would be difficult. Basic accounting software with spreadsheets can be accessed along with manual software, exerting a labour-intensive process. However, a thorough understanding of payroll laws and tax regulations is required to ensure accuracy.
Advantages of Manual Payroll
- Typically used with less expensive and low technical knowledge investment.
- For small businesses with few members in the organisation, work can be straightforward and manageable with manual software.
Disadvantages of Manual Payroll
- Manual payroll requires meticulously less accuracy than automated software, which is prone to human error that is prevalent.
- Handling manual payroll is based on one’s own trust capabilities. Errors in tax withholdings and misclassification in taxable benefits can end in costly disputes with tax authorities.
- Doing handy functions in manual payroll can be time-consuming and ensures more effort.
What is An Automated Payroll?
Automated payroll software assists in streamlining and synchronising all data; whatever is done, it calculates wages and withholds taxes and benefits. The automated payroll synchronises and functions with less human intervention by integrating attendance tracking and tax compliance.
The advancement of technology has propelled the shift to automated payroll software. According to a 2022 Deloitte survey, 27% of HR staff rely on manual software for payroll duties. However, due to a global benchmarking survey of Deloitte, the various employees are using automated payroll with several duties, as demonstrated in the image below:
Based on the image, today’s automated payroll software leverages advanced algorithms and cloud-based platforms to reduce errors with enhanced efficiency.
Learn more about the factors while choosing the best payroll software.
Comparison Between Advantages and Disadvantages of Automated Payroll Software
| Advantages of Automated Payroll | Disadvantages of Automated Payroll |
| Syncs with the Time Attendance Software to track attendance and effectively adds wages to employees’ payrolls without human assistance. | High budget in software setup and purchase. |
| Automatic Built-in feature to create and update tax filings in different regions based on their tax filing processes. | Time and effort to train about the new system. |
| Provides customisable payroll reports and insights for data analytics and analysis. | Risk of system downtime for payroll processing. |
| Allows the employees to access the portion of the salary in advance for urgent expenses. | |
| Allows employees to view their payslip and tax forms, download or upload them, and complete details online. |
Challenges Traditional Vs Automated Payroll Software
When Should You Switch From Manual Payroll to Automated Payroll?
Shifting from Traditional Vs Automated Payroll Software
Switching from manual software to automated payroll should follow scenarios such as:
Upscaling your business and increasing your employee count
As you upscale your organisation, the employee count increases, making payroll processing difficult. Therefore, it is crucial to use automated payroll software. It efficiently handles the payroll process without complexities and streamlines it with a larger workforce. Automated payroll systems ensure that all payroll operations are smooth and manageable, enabling your company to expand and evolve.
Time and Resource Constraints
Manual payroll software consume your time and resource constraints that overall impact efficiency. Here comes automated payroll software, which increases the organisation’s productivity. This shift is essential if we have substantially low manpower and if it is time-consuming, too. Automated software can free up valuable time and resources.
Know more about how easily you can tackle payroll localisation with HRMS in Hong Kong.
Low Error
Manual error always causes high discrepancies, with multiple errors and risk of compliance issues caused simultaneously using automated payroll software. These changes are highly impacted by the changing regulations, which cause human errors. Automated payroll software is built-in with advanced algorithms and up-to-date compliance regulatory features that minimise the risk of errors.
High Data Security
As to the increase of data breaches and phishing scams, everything should be secured enough with high confidentiality in an organisation. These systems are safeguarded with enhanced data security and highly encrypted protocols with confidential payroll data. This level of security is impossible with manual payroll software, whereas automated payroll software acts with enhanced data security.
Upscaling the Business
In the dynamic business growth process, business upscaling occurs only with automated payroll software, probably along with flexibility and scalability. As the business expands geographically with a diversified employee base, tackling payroll processing is difficult. So, it is better to integrate automated payroll software to make it easier to seamlessly overflow with the multiple tasks in payroll processing. Thus, this tool enacts crucial factors in catering for all business needs in all growth phases.
Work from Anywhere
As the business expands, instead of increasing the infrastructure, payroll processing can be handled anywhere in the comfort of the individual. The HR staff can use the automated payroll software remotely or onsite based on the individual’s workspace. The accessibility can be controlled, too, with restricted authority access by the owner.
Key Takeaways
According to this blog’s overview, with the highlights, automated payroll software has made a significantly greater leap than manual payroll software. According to the Global Payroll Association of Hong Kong, automated software reduces payroll processing by 80%. Due to its cost-effectiveness, this staggering figure entitles us to switch to automated payroll software. On the other hand, automated software can help the startup ensure centralised data, transparency, and enhanced security. Also, it promotes scalability in your business growth. However, spending a penny on automated payroll software makes you worthy in your business, which is better than manual payroll software.
Hope you got a valuable insight!
For more personalised discussion, contact us here.
